Review: The Letter Men – A Quiet Masterpiece of Queer Remembrance
It’s not every day that a story finds you — especially one as moving and improbable as that of The Letter Men. But that’s precisely what happened to director Andy Vallentine. In his own words, he stumbled across the love story of Gilbert Bradley and Gordon Bowsher while scrolling online, yet what followed was no casual discovery. It became a deeply personal pilgrimage to honour lives lived in secret, with love expressed in ink but forbidden in the flesh.
…No conception of what our love is…
…How far away we seem from the rest of the world…
Gilbert Bradley kept Gordon’s letters until he died in 2007, and they were then rediscovered in 2015. bringing their love story to light.
Based on the largest surviving collection of queer love letters from the Second World War, The Letter Men does more than dramatise a historical romance. It gives voice to the silenced — not in anger, but in reverence. Vallentine’s Director’s Statement reveals not only the historical weight of the story but also the emotional and ethical responsibility he felt in telling it. This isn’t opportunistic filmmaking; it’s stewardship.
The casting of Garrett Clayton as Gilbert and Matthew Postlethwaite as Gordon brings authenticity and tenderness to roles that could so easily have slipped into caricature. But under Vallentine’s hand, every gesture, glance, and silence feels earned. This is a film about longing — not just the yearning between two men separated by war, but the aching for recognition, dignity, and permanence in a world determined to forget them.
It’s also a visually rich experience. Oren Soffer’s cinematography is painterly, with the production and costume design capturing 1940s England not in sepia-toned nostalgia, but with a lived-in texture. Even the visual effects — subtle as they are — seem to serve the memory of these men, never overshadowing the human drama at the core.
What struck me most, however, wasn’t the historical significance — which is undeniable — but the contemporary resonance. As Vallentine notes, telling diverse, underrepresented stories is not just a moral imperative, but the very reason for making art at all. In a cultural moment where LGBTQ+ histories are still at risk of erasure or dismissal, The Letter Men becomes more than a film. It becomes testimony.
It’s a rare thing to watch a director so transparently moved by his subject and so determined to let it speak for itself. Andy Vallentine doesn’t just tell Gilbert and Gordon’s story; he listens to it. That humility, that attentiveness, is what elevates this short film into something unforgettable.
In the end, The Letter Men isn’t only about love letters. It is a love letter — to the past, to the possibility of queer futures, and to all those who wrote their truths down in hope, never knowing if anyone would ever read them.
Links: